Skip to content

Comments, corrections and subscriptions

Visitors can comment on articles and suggest corrections to articles and pages. Nothing a visitor writes appears on the site until someone on your team has approved it.

When something is waiting, a number appears beside Comments, Corrections or Readers in the sidebar, and on the Dashboard. Only admins see Readers in the sidebar. If the site sends email, everyone on the admin team is emailed about new comments, corrections and reader registrations as well.

Each article has its own Comments setting, in the article editor:

  • Enabled — anyone can comment: visitors can comment without an account, giving a name and, if they like, an email address (which is never shown). Readers who are logged in comment under their username.
  • Readers only — logged-in readers can comment: only visitors with a reader account who are logged in. Everyone else is invited to log in or register.
  • Closed — show existing, no new comments: approved comments stay visible, but nobody can add more.
  • Disabled — hide all comments: the comments section disappears from the article. Nothing is deleted; choose another setting to bring the comments back.

Replies to comments follow the same setting.

Visitors without an account write plain text. Logged-in readers get a small toolbar for bold, italics, lists, quotations and emoticons. Anything else is stripped out when they post.

A comment or correction can be up to 10,000 characters, and a name up to 80. Anything longer isn’t posted, and the page says That was too long to post.

Open Comments. Comments waiting for a decision come first. The buttons across the top show all, pending, approved or rejected comments.

Each comment shows who wrote it (with a reader badge for reader accounts, or the name and email an anonymous visitor gave), which article it’s on, and when. Then:

  • Approve puts it on the site.
  • Reject keeps it off the site. You can approve a rejected comment later, or reject an approved one to take it down.
  • Delete removes it and all its replies for good. Deleting needs the publisher or admin role, so editors don’t see the button.

Replies appear under their comment, with their own Approve, Reject and Delete buttons. A reply to an approved comment shows under all or approved, not under pending, so check all if the sidebar count doesn’t match what you see.

If a reader deletes their own comment after others have replied, the comment stays so the replies still make sense, marked Removed by its author. Kept because others replied. On the site it reads This comment was removed by its author.

When you approve or reject a reader’s comment, they’re emailed to say so, unless they’ve turned that off. Selecting Approve on a comment that’s already approved doesn’t email them again. When you approve a reply to a reader’s comment, they’re emailed about the reply.

Under any comment, open Reply as your name (staff), write your reply, and select Post staff reply. It goes on the site straight away, under your name with a Staff badge, and the comment’s author is emailed if they’re a reader.

Comments and corrections from visitors without an account pass some quiet checks, and anything that fails is thrown away without telling the sender. They’re dropped if they:

  • come from a place that has sent more than six comments or corrections in the last hour,
  • were sent within three seconds of the page loading (faster than a person types), or
  • contain a web address.

That last one catches most spam, but also a genuine visitor who pastes a link. Logged-in readers skip all of these checks.

Every article and page ends with Suggest a correction. Visitors open it, describe the problem under What needs fixing?, and select Send correction. Corrections don’t appear on the site; they come to you.

Open Corrections to see them, open ones first. Each shows what was suggested, the article or page it’s about (with a link to the live version and one to edit it), and when. Select Mark done once you’ve dealt with one (Reopen undoes that), or Delete it (publishers and admins only). The buttons across the top show all, open or done.

You can turn the form off for one article or page with its Disable corrections setting, or everywhere at once in Settings with Enable the “Suggest a correction” form. Turning it off everywhere is the simplest way to stop correction spam.

Readers with an account can subscribe to the blog. A logged-in reader who hasn’t subscribed sees Subscribe above an article’s comments; they can also subscribe or unsubscribe on their dashboard.

Subscribers are emailed the first time each article is published, whether you publish it yourself or it’s scheduled. Republishing an article doesn’t email them again. Readers can turn these emails off in their settings without unsubscribing.

All of this needs the site to send email. Without it, nobody is emailed and the dashboard counts and sidebar numbers are how you find out what’s waiting.